Home > 2013 > Credit Cards > Rewards Credit Cards: How to Pick One

Rewards Credit Cards: How to Pick One

Advertiser Disclosure Comments 2 Comments

Rewards Credit Cards: How To Pick OneDo you deserve a reward for being responsible? If you are paying your credit card’s balance in full every month, the credit card market is set up to offer you valuable rewards for your spending. All you have to do is choose one of the many reward credit cards.

And just like savvy savers choose the best investments based on their rate of return, smart rewards card users will choose the credit cards that offer the best returns for their spending. So how do you find the best reward card? There is no single best card for everyone, rather credit card users need to find the card that will return the best rewards possible for the kind of spending they do.

Research and compare rewards credit cards at Credit.com

Here are the key factors to look for:

Value per dollar spent. Over the long term, the most important thing about a rewards card will be how much value it returns for each dollar spent. For example, cash-back reward cards simply return a percentage of spending, while other products offer airline miles, hotel points, or other rewards. Then, it is up to the cardholder to place a value on those rewards in order to determine the value received for each dollar spent. In general, anything more than 2 cents per dollar is considered excellent, 1 to 2 cents is acceptable, and less than 1 cent is poor.

[Related Article: The First Thing To Do Before Applying For a Credit Card]

Free Credit Check & MonitoringSign-up bonus. Another feature common to many reward credit cards is the sign-up bonus. Banks offer new applicants a lump sum of rewards, usually after reaching a minimum spending requirement. In fact, there has been somewhat of a race between banks to offer the most attractive rewards, with some products featuring bonuses in the form of points or miles worth $1,000 or more.

Perks and benefits. Beyond points, miles, and cash back, many reward cards feature such things as travel insurance and purchase protection policies. Rewards credit cards co-branded with airlines and hotels can also offer impressive benefits when traveling, so don’t discount the value of these types of rewards.

Costs and fees. The best reward cards will have an annual fee, but there are still some entry level products that are offered for free. Some cards also have a foreign transaction fee that is added to all purchases made outside the country, but increasingly, many cards no longer have this fee.

New applicants should ensure that any fees paid are justified based on the value of the rewards. What is almost never justified is the higher interest rates normally present on reward cards. Those who carry a balance should always be using a card with the lowest interest rate available, not a rewards card.

[Free Resource: Check your credit score and report card for free before applying for a credit card]

A Few Good Credit Cards That Offer Rewards

Citi Platinum Select AAdvantage Visa Signature Card

Citi and American Airlines offer this co-branded rewards card that features airline miles plus plenty of other travel benefits. New cardholders earn 30,000 miles after spending just $1,000 within the first three months of opening their account, as well as earning one mile per dollar spent. Double miles are earned for purchases from American Airlines. Cardholders also receive priority boarding, a 25% discount on in-flight purchases, and their first bag checked for free. There is a $95 annual fee for this card that is waived the first year, and a 3% foreign transaction fee.

Chase Sapphire Preferred

This rewards card is like a Swiss Army Knife for travelers. Cardholders earn two points per dollar spent at restaurants and on travel expenses, and one point per dollar everywhere else. A third point is earned for travel booked through Chase’s Ultimate Rewards site. Once earned, Chase’s Ultimate Rewards points can be transferred to any of eight different airline and hotel programs, or to Amtrak Guest Rewards. Alternatively, points are worth 1.25 cents each when redeemed for travel booked through Chase’s site. The current sign-up bonus if 40,000 points after spending $3,000 within the first three months of opening an account. There is a $95 annual fee for this card that is waived the first year, and there are no foreign transaction fees.

Capital One VentureOne Rewards

Capital One offers this entry-level rewards card that earns 1.25 of their miles per dollar spent on all purchases. Each of their miles is worth one cent as a statement credit towards any travel purchase. There is no annual fee for this card and no foreign transaction fees. Capital One also offers its Venture Rewards card that features double miles on all purchases, but this card has a $59 annual fee that is waived the first year.

At publishing time, Citi Platinum Select AAdvantage Visa Signature Card, Chase Sapphire Preferred and Capital One VentureOne Rewards are offered through Credit.com product pages and Credit.com is compensated if our users apply for and ultimately sign up for any of these cards. However, this relationship does not result in any preferential editorial treatment.

Image: iStockphoto

Comments on articles and responses to those comments are not provided or commissioned by a bank advertiser. Responses have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by a bank advertiser. It is not a bank advertiser's responsibility to ensure all posts and/or questions are answered.

Please note that our comments are moderated, so it may take a little time before you see them on the page. Thanks for your patience.

  • Robert Munson

    Wow, you have got to be kidding! I cannot believe you have the email address ‘credit experts’ – you have missed the mark with your report by SO much that I can’t believe someone posted your ‘article’ as ‘information’. More like dis-information. The one factual thing you stated is “Over the long term, the most important thing about a rewards card will be how much value it returns for each dollar spent.” But then you failed to list the cards with the most value. You may be experts in other credit areas, but rewards credit cards isn’t one of them.

    First – there is one card that is vastly superior to any/all you named if you make frequent airline trips. If you don’t fly much, this is not the card for you. But the value of US Bank FlexPerks greatly exceeds all cards you listed. And, no, I don’t work for US Bank. I’m retired and I spend much of my time researching ‘the best’. Why FlexPerks?

    You get more than 1 point per dollar spent. You only get 1-1, but there are automatic double points for cell phone, tasting room purchases, and double for the highest of gas, groceries, airfare. Also, automatic triple points for charity donations. And each point is worth very close to 2 cents. So, the value is greater than 2 cents per dollar spent since you get more than 1 point per dollar. Currently it is actually greater than 3 cents per dollar spent, since you get 1/2 extra bonus point per dollar per month with US Bank Platinum checking, but that goes away August 10, 2013. I’m VERY disappointed at this development, but they realized they were providing too good of a deal. Well over 3 cents per dollar spent could not be sustained.

    How is the value ‘close’ to 2 cents per point? 20,000 points buys an airline ticket for up to $400 on 150 airlines. Plus, $25 credit is allowed to be spent on bags, food, etc. with the airline when traveling. Plus you earn the miles you fly – it is just like you bought a ticket with cash. And the multiple keeps working – 30K points for a ticket up to $600, 100K up to $2000 and so on.

    Since I acquired the card, I have redeemed 40K for a $796 ticket; 20K x 2 for $383 ticket and 30K for $586 ticket. Not quite 2 cents per point, but close. And, with more than 1 point per dollar, you are getting over 2 cents in value for each dollar spent on your credit card. Note the $383 tickets are SFO-NY-PHX flying (SFO-NY) the Fri before Thanksgiving and (NY-PHX) the Wed before Thanksgiving (United). I could have used 100K (50K each) United miles for those flights (double points for peak flying), or 40K FlexPerks points. Using your Starwood (25% bonus) “feature” I would have to spend $80K for the same flights free. And I wouldn’t get $25 credit and I wouldn’t get credit for the miles flown. HUGE difference. Since you get nearly 2 cents per point and more than 1 points per dollar, you get more than 2 cents per dollar spent.

    And you didn’t even mention this US Bank card. NO card you mentioned is providing more than 2 cents per dollar spent.

    Another card that I have has no annual fee and provides value that is more than 2 cents per dollar spent – Virgin America (around 2.2 cents). But, if you don’t fly Virgin America, this card has no utility for you.

    But, what really made me write this email is HOW FAR OFF YOU ARE ON AMERICAN EXPRESS HILTON SURPASS!!!!!!

    That card is horrible compared to the Citi Hilton card (imho) and you didn’t mention Citi, mainly because you get Gold status just for having the card vs. Amex’s silver. I canceled Amex and got Citi 10 weeks ago. But then a few days later Hilton announced an upcoming change to their reward structure, so I doubt that I will renew Citi when it comes up next year. Both Amex and Citi cards are horrible because Hilton is now horrible, from a ‘value the customer’ standpoint. But, with Citi you get free breakfast whenever you stay at Hilton because you are ‘lifetime’ Gold status when you have the Citi Hilton card. I am currently Hilton Diamond due to my spending on Amex last year, but I will no longer be diamond in 2014, because Gold gets you roughly the same benefits as Diamond. So direct your spending elsewhere – it isn’t worth it to spend $40K on the card to get Diamond status.

    But, why is Hilton so bad? Because, on March 28, 2013, their point structure changed. HUGE. They went from Hotel categories 1-7 to 1-10. Times Square Garden Inn went from Category 6 to 9. By the end of this year, I will have stayed in this property 3 times at 30K to 40K points per night. To show how bad they shafted the customers, a 9 night stay (extreme example) is 270K (9 x 40K less 25%) points in the old system. The new system is 640K points for the same 9 nights (8 x 80K with 1 free night). This is a 2.37 times increase (or devaluation of points depending on how you want to look at it). Hilton is doing away with their VIP discount (15-20-25% off for stays of 4, 5, 6 or more nights) and charging double the points per night for this property.

    So, when you said ‘up to 50K points for Hilton’s luxurious hotels’ you were off. A LOT. Make that almost double. 95K per night. The Times Square Garden Inn is hardly one of their upscale properties and it is 80K in June and November, when we are staying this year (using old points, since we booked March 27th).

    In the chart in the link above, a range of points per night is shown for the various categories. The ‘range’ of points required is based on season and can be found here:

    Anyway, when I saw your article I decided I would read it and see what I could learn. Sorry, but you are not experts. You need to get out more.

    Rebuttal welcome (and sought). I’m here to learn. I spend much of my time trying to maximize credit card rewards. I am sure you do too. But, the gap between my understanding and your presentation is large.

    In closing, to be fair, neither of the rewards cards that I claim to have greater value than what you present are worth much if you aren’t flying. The cards you highlighted may be preferable for every day use if you fly infrequently.
    Robert Munson
    Danville, CA

  • Jason Steele


    Thanks for your comment, as we definitely like to spark a healthy debate with these articles. Here are a few thoughts: I tried to offer a few examples of valuable reward cards, rather than a “best of”. I reserve those for our Best Credit Cards in America series. Sorry for the confusion. Nevertheless, I stand by the value of the three cards mentioned in this article as I happen to have personal experience with them.

    And while I share your displeasure with the extreme devaluation of the Hilton program, I never mentioned their cards in this article. In fact, I addressed this issue recently in this article: http://blog.credit.com/2013/03/have-hotel-chains-ruined-your-credit-card-rewards/

    No one ever said choosing a rewards card is easy, but I have been researching and writing about this topic since 2007, and I always enjoy hearing new opinions on this subject.

    Best of luck to you!

  • Pingback: Have Patience: Credit Cards That Pay Out Annually | Credit.com News + Advice()

  • Pingback: Is Being Debt-Free Always a Good Thing? | Credit.com News + Advice()

  • Pingback: Airline Rewards Credit Cards: How to Pick One | Best Credit Repair()

  • Pingback: How to Get Paid for Business Travel | Credit.com News + Advice()

  • Pingback: How to Get Paid for Business Travel | Experts Bto()

  • Pingback: How to Get Paid for Business Travel | Best Credit Repair()

  • Pingback: How to Get Paid for Business Travel « Tony Rocha Official Blog()

  • Pingback: The Best Credit Cards In America for Cash Rewards | Credit.com News + Advice()

  • Pingback: 5 Unusual Credit Cards That Carry The Best Rewards | Business Loans Guide()

  • Pingback: 12 Ways to Cut Costs at the Grocery Store | Best Credit Repair()

  • Pingback: CyberBuzzer - Plug Yourself! » Credit Cards for Sports Fans: A Closer Look()

  • Pingback: Credit Cards for Sports Fans Rated()

  • Pingback: Credit Cards for Sports Fans: A Closer Look | CyberBuzzer()

Certain credit cards and other financial products mentioned in this and other articles on Credit.com News & Advice may also be offered through Credit.com product pages, and Credit.com will be compensated if our users apply for and ultimately sign up for any of these cards or products. However, this relationship does not result in any preferential editorial treatment.