Home > 2011 > Managing Debt > Pre-Paid Debt Settlement, Rest in Peace

Pre-Paid Debt Settlement, Rest in Peace

Advertiser Disclosure Comments 3 Comments

One nearly dead, one dying fast. For consumers looking for low-cost ways to borrow money and get out of debt, the downfall of two entire industries may actually be good news, consumer advocates say.

The first lending industry on the ropes was tax anticipation loans. A series of regulatory changes could make 2011 the last year that companies can offer loans based on tax returns, which we covered here. Now the pre-paid debt settlement industry may be entering its final days, insiders say.

A rule imposed in October 2010 by the Federal Trade Commission banned companies from charging money up-front before doing any work to resolve a consumer’s outstanding debts.

[Resource: Tips for Paying Off Credit Card Debt]

That single rule change has caused membership in The Association of Settlement Companies (TASC) to plummet 70% in the last six months, says Eric Thompson, founder of Denver-based Prestige Financial Services, which switched from a pre-paid to pay-as-you-go model two years ago. Thompson began tracking the number of members listed on the TASC web site soon before the rule took effect.

While he didn’t confirm the exact numbers, Robert Linderman, vice president of TASC’s board of directors, says, “It’s a good approximation. And we don’t view that necessarily as a negative.”

According to Linderman, the huge reduction in TASC’s membership was partly due to the fact that the association now only accepts companies that follow the FTC’s rule by charging only after they actually resolve a debt.

“We want the industry to become much more respectable, to be recognized for the incredible value we provide to consumers,” says Linderman, who says the industry’s internal research finds that it resolved $1 billion worth of unpaid debts in 2010 and saved consumers between $400 and $500 million.

Some companies changed voluntarily, before the FTC rule took effect.

“We saw the writing on the wall,” says Thompson of Prestige Financial Services. He agrees with Linderman’s assessment about changes in the industry. “You’re taking delicate consumers and charging them money and not even providing a service. When you can eliminate that, I think it’s fantastic.”

[Resource: Consumer Guide to Debt Settlement]

Some companies continue to charge upfront fees by presenting themselves as attorney services, which are not covered under the FTC rule, says Gerri Detweiler, Credit.com’s credit expert. This is a dangerous bait-and-switch, Thompson says, since most companies use an attorney as a frontman but turn the debt reduction work itself over to non-attorneys.

“The industry is definitely being weeded out, and a lot of players who were relying on charging clients big upfront fees are gone,” Detweiler says. “That’s a good thing.”

Legitimate debt reduction services, which charge only after they succeed in reducing a consumer’s debt, still play an important role, Detweiler says. By working with so many consumers, they know which lenders are most willing to negotiate versus those most likely to sue. That’s important information that most people would never know, and it can help consumers know which debts they should settle first.

“And with the FTC rule, it gives the companies more incentive to screen for clients that are good candidates for settlement, so they’re more likely to only take on clients that can be successful,” Detweiler says.

A similar squeeze is hitting the tax anticipation loan industry now, as new regulations by the IRS, FDIC and the Office of Thrift Supervision make it increasingly difficult for companies like Jackson Hewitt and H&R Block to get the capital they need to offer loans, according to a recent report by the National Consumer Law Center and the Consumer Federation of America.

Image: quaziefoto, via Flickr

Comments on articles and responses to those comments are not provided or commissioned by a bank advertiser. Responses have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by a bank advertiser. It is not a bank advertiser's responsibility to ensure all posts and/or questions are answered.

Please note that our comments are moderated, so it may take a little time before you see them on the page. Thanks for your patience.

  • Pingback: Debt Settlement Attorneys Might Help Save Somebody Tons Of Cash()

  • James C. Gibbs

    I was one of those people who paid one thousand dollars up front. I was told that they would contact the credit card companies that I owed money and have my interest rate reduced to at least twelve per cent. I said how can you do this and they replied that they had a staff of attorney’s who dealt with this on a daily basis. The only thing that I received was a computer generated booklet that showed how to pay off your debt in an systematic way. The booklet did not address my need. I wrote to them and received a telephone call from them. They would not answer my questions concerning the interest rate reduction that they promised. Toward the end of the conversation they said that they would look at my plan and see what they could do for me. That was four months ago and I haven’t heard from them.

    Their name is Ist Financial Asset Services But the shipping return address was Corporate Fulfillment center, 201 S. Lincoln Ave. Clearwater, Fl. 33756-5821.

  • Anniey Tom

    Availing the service of a debt settlement company entails careful consideration. Moreover, choosing a debt settlement company requires further thinking and cautious research because of 2 reasons:

    — You need to invest your time and effort to a debt settlement company that is both reliable and effective.
    — Scammers and fraudulent debt settlement companies are scattered everywhere.

  • Carol LaMartina

    Hello, I just Quit Morgan Drexen Integrated Legal Sysatems, which supports Levinson Consumer Attorneys. I answered a question from a TV program and they were an offer I could accept. Sorry I did! I was loaned $1,000.00 I did not realize why until I asked how much money was in my account ($O). They got their money up front. I was also paying $50 a month for 11months for a service fee. (pre-paid envelopes). I lost $1650.00, and I still owe them $245. They told me they would not take any more money from my account, but I received a bill with the next draw being 5/3/2011.
    I am also being sued by Chase, how does that happen?
    they were gonna call me and ask for another $151.00 a month to cover the settlement they made with Chase Bank on my behalf. I also read in the contract that they get 25% of the difference between the actual debt and what they settle for. I got hooked. What I was told did not happen and I will be out over $2000.00, and no debt paid, and my husband is working part time, I lost my Health Ins.. I was working with my Disability check only.
    These people are in California, and are now advertising on TV, under Morgn Drexen, said only once. 1600 DOUGLASS ROAD, SUITE 100 ANAHEIM CA. 92806

Certain credit cards and other financial products mentioned in this and other articles on Credit.com News & Advice may also be offered through Credit.com product pages, and Credit.com will be compensated if our users apply for and ultimately sign up for any of these cards or products. However, this relationship does not result in any preferential editorial treatment.