Personal Finance

Are the Deregulators Trying to Destroy the Economy?

Comments 3 Comments

I understand that deregulators are committed to an ideology. We all need something to believe in, after all, and they believe in the power of markets to both create growth and self-regulate. That’s all very nice and looks good on paper, but given the past few years, that argument simply doesn’t pass the straight face test. I mean, let’s be real, deregulation nearly destroyed our economy as the past few years clearly demonstrate. But the deregulators aren’t giving up… and maybe they won’t until they’ve finished the job.

To quote Ronald Reagan, “There you go again.”

When the CARD Act was enacted, followed by the passage of the Dodd-Frank Act, I — along with almost every person who fogged a mirror in Washington — heard that the financial services industry was telling their constituent members, “Fear not, we have two more bites at the apple” – when the regulations are promulgated to flesh out the broad mandates of the laws and when budget time rolls around.

[Related: Are CARD Act Critics in Complete Denial?]

Well, they didn’t do so well at the first tranche of regulations, but I draw your attention to Section 1517 of the Continuing Resolution to fund government operations (also known as “Scream 5,” or the $60 billion budget slash fest).

The TGODs (the folks who wish to return to The Good Old Days) have slipped in a tiny provision that restricts the annual budget for the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau to $80 million in Fiscal 2011 (which ends in October). This is a reduction from $143 million and couldn’t come at a worse time for the regulator, or a better time for the regulated.

Reps. Barney Frank (D-MA), Rush Holt (D-NJ) and Brad Miller (D-NC) —(collectively “FHM”) — sent a letter to their colleagues saying that this “is a clear attempt to hamstring the new, independent agency as it hires staff and begins the critical work of providing clarity and security to the system of consumer finance.”

FHM went on to say, “This attempt is particularly concerning, because last year after an open process that included a rare, televised House-Senate conference, Congress agreed that in order for this new financial watchdog to be effective, it must be independent and adequately funded. By deriving its operating budget from the Federal Reserve, it would be insulated from the types of partisan fights on Capitol Hill in which we find ourselves today.”

President Obama signs the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act, July 21, 2010.

Section 1517 seems to blatantly contradict both the letter and intent of the Financial Reform Act, which states that the CFPB’s funding be “derived from the Federal Reserve System pursuant to this subsection [and] shall NOT (emphasis added) be subject to review by the Committees on Appropriations of the House of Representatives and the Senate.”

[Related: The GOP’s Plans for Financial Reform]

Is it possible that the TGODs never got that memo? Is it more likely that the contributions from their friends in financial services have caused them to focus more on their bottom line than ours? Or, is it possible that they are in a frenzy to send the message that they are the Sweeny Todds of Constitution Avenue and that consumer protection is so … last year?

Rather than directly limiting the CFPB’s appropriation, Section 1517 merely seeks to prevent the Fed from disbursing the money to the CFPB. It’s an audacious maneuver, one that the big banks and their congressional compatriots are probably pretty proud of.  But make no mistake: undermining the CFPB is bad for the nation and its citizens, most of whom are barely treading water in this lifeless economy. Banks are too focused on the immediate bottom line and still, inconceivably, fail to see the big picture.

The Big Picture & Consumer Protections (cont.) »

Washington DC photo by lawgeek, via Flickr
Official White House Photo by Lawrence Jackson

Pages: 1 2

Please note that our comments are moderated, so it may take a little time before you see them on the page. Thanks for your patience.

  • Jon

    Hmmm… “deregulation nearly destroyed our economy as the past few years clearly demonstrate”… I could be argued that government involvement in the lending industry in the first place is what nearly destroyed our economy. But hey, neat way to start an article, stating a premise as fact when there’s actually arguments on both sides of the issue. Let me try that… Adam Levin stands to make more money with more government regulation as this article clearly demonstrates. Yep, that was easy. Who needs to back anything up with facts when we can just say it’s “clearly demonstrated”.

  • DD

    It can’t be successfully argued that government caused the meltdown unless the argument is government failed to properly monitor and regulate. /end arguing with blinded partisan

  • Jon

    dd, from 1996 to 2005, the US Gov’t had been increasing the target on the % of low income loans (read sub-prime) Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac purchased. During that period, the target started at 42% and ended at 52%. These two Government Sponsored Enterprises account for something like half of all mortgages nationally. And depending on the year, they buy or guarantee well more than 50%.

    The way I see it, and the way a lot of other people see it, the USG basically CREATED a market for Sub-prime loans. So, would that need to be regulated? Sure. If you’re going to artificially create a market for sub-prime loans, they probably should regulated the crap out of it. Why wouldn’t banks/lenders grant a bunch of stupid loans, when there’s a built in buyer funded by the USG willing to buy it and take on the risk.

    But, my point is, if the market for sub-prime hadn’t been artificially created by the government in the first place, the sub-prime meltdown wouldn’t have happened.

    “end arguing with blinded partisan”… well, hello pot, meet kettle.

  • Pingback: Consumer Financial Protection Bureau May See Significant Budget Slashes « Howtofixmycredit.com

  • Pingback: Adam Levin: Holy Anniversary! Gotham, the CFPB and the Army of Darkness | Get Better Info

Find out where you stand.
Get your FREE personalized credit report card.

Sign Up Now
X

Stay Connected to Our Experts

Please submit your email address to get credit & money tips & advice
from our team of 30+ experts, delivered weekly to your inbox.